<document tableId="1B8696AB5033FFF9FD5DFAF496AF940E" sourceDocId="3B690F4D5039FFF3FFCFFFDA9617932F" captionStart="data" checkinTime="1699385046528" checkinUser="plazi" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" updateTime="1699385046528" updateUser="plazi"><mods:mods xmlns:mods="http://www.loc.gov/mods/v3">
    <mods:titleInfo>
        <mods:title>Novel splitting / lumping index reflects the history of species concepts applied to bumblebees (Insecta: Apidae)</mods:title>
    </mods:titleInfo>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Williams, Paul H</mods:namePart>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:typeOfResource>text</mods:typeOfResource>
    <mods:relatedItem type="host">
        <mods:titleInfo>
            <mods:title>Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society</mods:title>
        </mods:titleInfo>
        <mods:part>
            <mods:date>2022</mods:date>
            <mods:detail type="pubDate">
                <mods:number>2022-10-01</mods:number>
            </mods:detail>
            <mods:detail type="volume">
                <mods:number>196</mods:number>
            </mods:detail>
            <mods:detail type="issue">
                <mods:number>2</mods:number>
            </mods:detail>
            <mods:extent unit="page">
                <mods:start>704</mods:start>
                <mods:end>719</mods:end>
            </mods:extent>
        </mods:part>
    </mods:relatedItem>
    <mods:location>
        <mods:url>https://academic.oup.com/zoolinnean/article/196/2/704/6540035</mods:url>
    </mods:location>
    <mods:classification>journal article</mods:classification>
    <mods:identifier type="DOI">10.1093/zoolinnean/zlab123</mods:identifier>
    <mods:identifier type="ISSN">0024-4082</mods:identifier>
    <mods:identifier type="Zenodo-Dep">7184415</mods:identifier>
</mods:mods>
<table id="1B8696AB5033FFF9FD5DFAF496AF940E"><caption inLine="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" startId="10.[162,184,1685,1795]"><superScript attach="right" box="[658,676,1281,1365]" fontSize="7" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">data from</superScript> <subScript attach="right" box="[658,676,1370,1417]" fontSize="7" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">using</subScript> Continued <superScript attach="right" box="[658,676,1423,1602]" fontSize="7" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">secretions, compared</superScript> cephalic <superScript attach="right" box="[658,676,1607,1710]" fontSize="7" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">labial gland</superScript> <emphasis bold="true" box="[162,184,1811,1896]" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">Table 4</emphasis></caption><thead><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFF16FF1E96F89448"><th box="[217,239,1557,1895]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF16F9CF96F89448" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Source</th><th box="[217,239,1404,1531]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF16FAA696F896D4" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Smith, 1854</th><th box="[217,239,1258,1377]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF16FB3096F8964E" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">von Dalla</th><th box="[217,239,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF16FBF496F897E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Skorikov, 1923</th><th box="[217,239,914,1043]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF16FC4896F8973C" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Reinig, 1935</th><th box="[217,239,704,859]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF16FD1A96F89074" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Williams, 1998</th><th box="[217,239,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF16FE6696F89172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Williams <emphasis box="[217,239,460,504]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FF16FE3C96F892CE" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">et al</emphasis>.,</th><th box="[217,239,196,379]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF16FF1E96F89254" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Combined list of</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFF38FF1E971A9448"><th id="B218AD1D5033000CFF38F9CF971A9448"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFF38FAA6971A96D4"/><td box="[247,269,1258,1377]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF38FB30971A964E" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><bibRefCitation author="von Dalla Torre KW" box="[247,269,1258,1377]" firstAuthor="Dalla von" id="2B68BBD25033FFF9FF38FAFD971A9633" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" refId="ref7935" refString="von Dalla Torre KW. 1896. Catalogus hymenopterorum hucusque descriptorum systematicus et synonymicus, Vol. X: Apidae (Anthophila). Leipzig: Engelmann." type="book" year="1896">Torre, 1896</bibRefCitation></td><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFF38FBF4971A97E9"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFF38FC48971A973C"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFF38FD1A971A9074"/><td box="[247,269,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF38FE66971A9172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">2020 (‘ present’)</td><td box="[247,269,196,379]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFF38FF1E971A9254" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">candidate species</td></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFEE6FF1E97289448"><th id="B218AD1D5033000CFEE6F9CF97289448"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFEE6FAA6972896D4"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFEE6FB309728964E"/><td box="[297,319,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEE6FBF4972897E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">*</td><td box="[297,319,914,1043]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEE6FC489728973C" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">*</td><td box="[297,319,704,859]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEE6FD1A97289074" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">*</td><td box="[297,319,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEE6FE6697289172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">qilianensis</td><td box="[297,319,196,379]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEE6FF1E97289254" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">qilianensis</td></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFE88FF1E974A9448"><th id="B218AD1D5033000CFE88F9CF974A9448"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE88FAA6974A96D4"/><td box="[327,349,1258,1377]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE88FB30974A964E" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Morawitz" authorityYear="1887" box="[327,349,1285,1377]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FE88FADF974A964E" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="keriensis"><emphasis box="[327,349,1285,1377]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FE88FADF974A964E" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">keriensis</emphasis></taxonomicName></td><td box="[327,349,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE88FBF4974A97E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Morawitz" authorityYear="1887" box="[327,349,1130,1222]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FE88FBB0974A97E9" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="keriensis">keriensis</taxonomicName></td><td box="[327,349,914,1043]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE88FC48974A973C" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Morawitz" authorityYear="1887" box="[327,349,951,1043]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FE88FC6D974A973C" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="keriensis"><emphasis box="[327,349,951,1043]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FE88FC6D974A973C" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">keriensis</emphasis></taxonomicName></td><td box="[327,349,704,859]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE88FD1A974A9074" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Morawitz" authorityYear="1887" box="[327,349,767,859]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FE88FD25974A9074" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="keriensis"><emphasis box="[327,349,767,859]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FE88FD25974A9074" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">keriensis</emphasis></taxonomicName></td><td box="[327,349,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE88FE66974A9172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Morawitz" authorityYear="1887" box="[327,349,512,604]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FE88FDDA974A9173" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="keriensis">keriensis</taxonomicName></td><td box="[327,349,196,379]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE88FF1E974A9254" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Morawitz" authorityYear="1887" box="[327,349,287,379]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FE88FEC5974A9254" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="keriensis">keriensis</taxonomicName></td></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFEAAFF1E976C9448"><th id="B218AD1D5033000CFEAAF9CF976C9448"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFEAAFAA6976C96D4"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFEAAFB30976C964E"/><td box="[357,379,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEAAFBF4976C97E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Vogt" authorityYear="1909" box="[357,379,1101,1222]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FEAAFB97976C97E9" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="separandus">separandus</taxonomicName></td><td box="[357,379,914,1043]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEAAFC48976C973C" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">x</td><td box="[357,379,704,859]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEAAFD1A976C9074" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">x</td><td box="[357,379,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEAAFE66976C9172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Vogt" authorityYear="1909" box="[357,379,483,604]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FEAAFE39976C9173" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="separandus"><emphasis box="[357,379,483,604]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FEAAFE39976C9173" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">separandus</emphasis></taxonomicName></td><td box="[357,379,196,379]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFEAAFF1E976C9254" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Vogt" authorityYear="1909" box="[357,379,258,379]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FEAAFED8976C9254" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="separandus">separandus</taxonomicName></td></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFE4CFF1E978E9448"><th id="B218AD1D5033000CFE4CF9CF978E9448"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE4CFAA6978E96D4"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE4CFB30978E964E"/><td box="[387,409,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE4CFBF4978E97E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Skorikov" authorityYear="1910" box="[387,409,1149,1222]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FE4CFBA7978E97E9" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="kozlovi"><emphasis box="[387,409,1149,1222]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FE4CFBA7978E97E9" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">kozlovi</emphasis></taxonomicName></td><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE4CFC48978E973C"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE4CFD1A978E9074"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE4CFE66978E9172"/><td box="[387,409,196,379]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE4CFF1E978E9254" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu"><taxonomicName _evidence="document" _step="nonLabeled1" authorityName="Skorikov" authorityYear="1910" box="[387,409,306,379]" class="Insecta" family="Apidae" genus="Bombus" id="88F9BDA05033FFF9FE4CFEE8978E9254" kingdom="Animalia" order="Hymenoptera" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" phylum="Arthropoda" rank="species" species="kozlovi"><emphasis box="[387,409,306,379]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FE4CFEE8978E9254" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">kozlovi</emphasis></taxonomicName></td></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFE6EFF1E97A09448"><th box="[417,439,1557,1895]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE6EF9CF97A09448" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">All taxa in species-group de-</th><td box="[417,439,1404,1531]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE6EFAA697A096D4" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">14</td><td box="[417,439,1258,1377]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE6EFB3097A0964E" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">32</td><td box="[417,439,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE6EFBF497A097E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">69</td><td box="[417,439,914,1043]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE6EFC4897A0973C" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">100</td><td box="[417,439,704,859]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE6EFD1A97A09074" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">114</td><td box="[417,439,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE6EFE6697A09172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">116</td><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE6EFF1E97A09254"/></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFE70FF1E97C29448"><th box="[447,469,1557,1895]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE70F9CF97C29448" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">scribed to date</th><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE70FAA697C296D4"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE70FB3097C2964E"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE70FBF497C297E9"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE70FC4897C2973C"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE70FD1A97C29074"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE70FE6697C29172"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE70FF1E97C29254"/></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFE12FF1E97E49448"><th box="[477,499,1404,1895]" colspan="2" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE12FAA697E49448" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Present species described to date 6</th><td box="[477,499,1258,1377]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE12FB3097E4964E" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">13</td><td box="[477,499,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE12FBF497E497E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">19</td><td box="[477,499,914,1043]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE12FC4897E4973C" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">21</td><td box="[477,499,704,859]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE12FD1A97E49074" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">23</td><td box="[477,499,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE12FE6697E49172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">25</td><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE12FF1E97E49254"/></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFE34FF1E94069448"><th box="[507,529,1404,1895]" colspan="2" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE34FAA694069448" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">Present species described to date 6</th><td box="[507,529,1258,1377]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE34FB309406964E" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">13</td><td box="[507,529,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE34FBF4940697E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">21</td><td box="[507,529,914,1043]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE34FC489406973C" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">17</td><td box="[507,529,704,859]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE34FD1A94069074" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">25</td><td box="[507,529,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFE34FE6694069172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">25</td><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFE34FF1E94069254"/></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFDD7FF1E945B9448"><th box="[536,588,1557,1895]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFDD7F9CF945B9448" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">or examined by author (<emphasis box="[536,558,1605,1620]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FDD7F99F9439957B" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">S</emphasis> <emphasis box="[550,563,1597,1606]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FDE9F9E794249569" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714"><subScript attach="left" box="[550,563,1597,1606]" fontSize="5" id="D37DC4665033FFF9FDE9F9E794249569" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">P</subScript></emphasis>) Total species reported by author</th><td box="[536,588,1404,1531]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFDD7FAA6945B96D4" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">6</td><td box="[536,588,1258,1377]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFDD7FB30945B964E" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">13</td><td box="[536,588,1070,1222]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFDD7FBF4945B97E9" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">30</td><td box="[536,588,914,1043]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFDD7FC48945B973C" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">10</td><td box="[536,588,704,859]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFDD7FD1A945B9074" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">17</td><td box="[536,588,444,605]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFDD7FE66945B9172" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">25</td><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFDD7FF1E945B9254"/></tr><tr id="F1C9C4615033000CFD9CFF1E94789448"><th box="[595,623,1557,1895]" id="B218AD1D5033000CFD9CF9CF94789448" pageId="10" pageNumber="714" textDirection="bu">(<emphasis box="[595,617,1849,1864]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FD9CF8E3947E9467" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">S</emphasis> <emphasis box="[610,623,1840,1849]" id="7D8D1A315033FFF9FDADF8EA94789416" italics="true" pageId="10" pageNumber="714">A</emphasis>)</th><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFD9CFAA6947896D4"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFD9CFB309478964E"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFD9CFBF4947897E9"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFD9CFC489478973C"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFD9CFD1A94789074"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFD9CFE6694789172"/><td id="B218AD1D5033000CFD9CFF1E94789254"/></tr></tbody></table></document>