<document tableId="DF0068CFFFA4EA5CFFBF13A11C277B9E" sourceDocId="FFEFF129FFBCEA44FFC2126D1F167A63" ID-DOI="http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.16739801" ID-Zenodo-Dep="16739801" captionStart="Table 5" checkinTime="1754328720860" checkinUser="guilherme" pageId="24" pageNumber="25" updateTime="1754331413593" updateUser="guilherme"><mods:mods xmlns:mods="http://www.loc.gov/mods/v3">
    <mods:titleInfo>
        <mods:title>An integrative taxonomy investigation unravels a cryptic species of Mobula Rafinesque, 1810 (Mobulidae, Myliobatiformes), from the Atlantic Ocean</mods:title>
    </mods:titleInfo>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Bucair, Nayara</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Departamento de Oceanografia Biológica, Laboratório de Ecologia da Reprodução e do Recrutamento de Organismos Marinhos (ECORREP), Instituto Oceanográfico, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil &amp; Programa de Pós-Graduação Em Oceanografia, Instituto Oceanográfico, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil</mods:affiliation>
        <mods:nameIdentifier type="email">nayarabucair@usp.br</mods:nameIdentifier>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Hinojosa-Alvarez, Silvia</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Tecnológico de Monterrey, School of Engineering and Sciences, Monterrey, Nuevo León, Mexico</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Marshall, Andrea Denise</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Marine Megafauna Foundation, West Palm Beach, FL, USA</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Pate, Jessica</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Marine Megafauna Foundation, West Palm Beach, FL, USA</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Francini, Carlo Leopoldo Bezerra</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Projeto Mantas Do Brasil, Instituto Laje Viva, Santos, SP, Brazil</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Garrido, Amana Guedes</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Center of Marine Biology, University of São Paulo, São Sebastião, SP, Brazil</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Capel, Katia Cristina Cruz</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Center of Marine Biology, University of São Paulo, São Sebastião, SP, Brazil &amp; Department of Genetics and Evolution, Federal University of São Carlos, São Carlos, SP, Brazil</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Loboda, Thiago Silva</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Museu de Zoologia da Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, SP, Brazil</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Monteiro, Jhonatas Sirino</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Center of Marine Biology, University of São Paulo, São Sebastião, SP, Brazil</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Bruno, Carlos Eduardo Malavasi</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Departamento de Tecnologia Dos Alimentos, Faculdade de Veterinária, Universidade Federal Fluminense, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Vaga, Claudia Francesca</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Department of Invertebrate Zoology, National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC, USA</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Dove, Alistair D. M.</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Museum of Science &amp; History, Jacksonville, FL, USA</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Hoopes, Lisa A.</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>IUCN Center for Species Survival, Georgia Aquarium, Atlanta, GA, USA</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Perry, Cameron</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>IUCN Center for Species Survival, Georgia Aquarium, Atlanta, GA, USA</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:name type="personal">
        <mods:role>
            <mods:roleTerm>Author</mods:roleTerm>
        </mods:role>
        <mods:namePart>Kitahara, Marcelo V.</mods:namePart>
        <mods:affiliation>Center of Marine Biology, University of São Paulo, São Sebastião, SP, Brazil</mods:affiliation>
    </mods:name>
    <mods:typeOfResource>text</mods:typeOfResource>
    <mods:relatedItem type="host">
        <mods:titleInfo>
            <mods:title>Environmental Biology of Fishes</mods:title>
        </mods:titleInfo>
        <mods:part>
            <mods:date>2025</mods:date>
            <mods:detail type="pubDate">
                <mods:number>2025-07-23</mods:number>
            </mods:detail>
            <mods:detail type="volume">
                <mods:number>108</mods:number>
            </mods:detail>
            <mods:extent unit="page">
                <mods:start>1</mods:start>
                <mods:end>35</mods:end>
            </mods:extent>
        </mods:part>
    </mods:relatedItem>
    <mods:location>
        <mods:url>https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-025-01727-2</mods:url>
    </mods:location>
    <mods:classification>journal article</mods:classification>
    <mods:identifier type="CLB-Dataset">311514</mods:identifier>
    <mods:identifier type="DOI">10.1007/s10641-025-01727-2</mods:identifier>
    <mods:identifier type="GBIF-Dataset">3df32396-68db-4742-ae1f-e484de47f3b3</mods:identifier>
    <mods:identifier type="Zenodo-Dep">16739693</mods:identifier>
</mods:mods>
<table id="DF0068CFFFA4EA5CFFBF13A11C277B9E"><caption pageId="24" pageNumber="25" startId="24.[125,179,460,481]" targetType="table"><emphasis bold="true" box="[125,196,460,481]" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Table 5</emphasis> Percentage of colour criteria analysed for manta ray identification. Criteria in bold highlight the hypothesis of&gt;95% (feature present) and &lt;5% (feature absence) in species distinction characteristics</caption><thead><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF107F1A3C783E"><th box="[125,854,530,605]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF107F1C40783E" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Criteria</th><th box="[923,1029,530,605]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC59107F1B13783E" pageId="24" pageNumber="25"><taxonomicName _evidence="catalog+fontStyle" _step="styledSpecies" box="[923,1029,530,552]" class="Elasmobranchii" family="Mobulidae" genus="Mobula" id="4C7F43C4FFA4EA5CFC59107E1B137844" kingdom="Animalia" order="Myliobatiformes" pageId="24" pageNumber="25" phylum="Chordata" rank="species" species="birostris">M. birostris</taxonomicName></th><th box="[1098,1189,530,605]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB88107F1BB3783E" pageId="24" pageNumber="25"><taxonomicName _evidence="catalog+fontStyle" _step="styledSpecies" box="[1098,1189,530,552]" class="Elasmobranchii" family="Mobulidae" genus="Mobula" id="4C7F43C4FFA4EA5CFB88107E1BB37844" kingdom="Animalia" order="Myliobatiformes" pageId="24" pageNumber="25" phylum="Chordata" rank="species" species="alfredi">M. alfredi</taxonomicName></th><th box="[1257,1322,530,605]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B107F1A3C783E" pageId="24" pageNumber="25"><taxonomicName _evidence="catalog+fontStyle" _step="styledSpecies" authorityName="Bucair &amp; Marshall" authorityYear="2025" class="Elasmobranchii" family="Mobulidae" genus="Mobula" id="4C7F43C4FFA4EA5CFB2B107E1A0A7820" kingdom="Animalia" order="Myliobatiformes" pageId="24" pageNumber="25" phylum="Chordata" rank="species" species="yarae" status="sp. nov">M. yarae</taxonomicName> <taxonomicNameLabel box="[1257,1322,584,605]" id="A238592EFFA4EA5CFB2B10251A3C783E" pageId="24" pageNumber="25" rank="species">sp. nov</taxonomicNameLabel></th></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF10171A3C78EC"><th box="[125,1322,634,655]" colspan="4" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF10171A3C78EC" pageId="24" pageNumber="25"><emphasis bold="true" box="[125,189,634,655]" id="B90BE455FFA4EA5CFFBF10171FAB78EC" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Dorsal</emphasis></th></tr></thead><tbody><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF10F61A3C78D2"><th box="[125,854,667,689]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF10F61C4078D2" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Presence of white supra-branchial patches</th><td box="[923,1029,667,689]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5910F61B1378D2" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td><td box="[1098,1189,667,689]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8810F61BB378D2" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td><td box="[1257,1322,667,689]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B10F61A3C78D2" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF10D01A3C78B0"><th box="[125,854,701,723]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF10D01C4078B0" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">White triangular supra-branchial patches extends medially or anterior of spiracle</th><td box="[923,1029,701,723]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5910D01B1378B0" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td><td box="[1098,1189,701,723]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8810D01BB378B0" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">0</td><td box="[1257,1322,701,723]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B10D01A3C78B0" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">56.9</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF10B31A3C7897"><th box="[125,854,734,756]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF10B31C407897" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">White posterior-facing “hooks” on the lateral supra-branchial patches</th><td box="[923,1029,734,756]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5910B31B137897" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">98</td><td box="[1098,1189,734,756]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8810B31BB37897" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">72.7</td><td box="[1257,1322,734,756]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B10B31A3C7897" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">89</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF10921A3C7976"><th box="[125,854,767,789]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF10921C407976" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">White supra-branchial patches~ 90° posterior-facing</th><td box="[923,1029,767,789]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5910921B137976" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td><td box="[1098,1189,767,789]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8810921BB37976" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">0</td><td box="[1257,1322,767,789]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B10921A3C7976" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">0</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF114D1A3C7955"><th box="[125,854,800,822]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF114D1C407955" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">White supra-branchial patches remain parallel or slightly tapered</th><td box="[923,1029,800,822]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC59114D1B137955" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td><td box="[1098,1189,800,822]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB88114D1BB37955" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">0</td><td box="[1257,1322,800,822]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B114D1A3C7955" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">0</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF112F1A3C793B"><th box="[125,854,834,856]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF112F1C40793B" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Supra-branchial patches do not touch</th><td box="[923,1029,834,856]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC59112F1B13793B" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td><td box="[1098,1189,834,856]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB88112F1BB3793B" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">86.5</td><td box="[1257,1322,834,856]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B112F1A3C793B" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">88.2</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF110E1A3C791A"><th box="[125,854,867,889]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF110E1C40791A" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Abrupt/sharp transition between white and black dorsal colours</th><td box="[923,1029,867,889]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC59110E1B13791A" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td><td box="[1098,1189,867,889]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB88110E1BB3791A" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">1</td><td box="[1257,1322,867,889]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B110E1A3C791A" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">20.5</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF11E91A3C79F9"><th box="[125,854,900,922]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF11E91C4079F9" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Dark line above the mouth</th><td box="[923,1029,900,922]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5911E91B1379F9" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">98</td><td box="[1098,1189,900,922]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8811E91BB379F9" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">18.2</td><td box="[1257,1322,900,922]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B11E91A3C79F9" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">53.7</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF11C81A3C79D8"><th box="[125,854,933,955]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF11C81C4079D8" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Eye pattern</th><td box="[923,1029,933,955]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5911C81B1379D8" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">95.3</td><td box="[1098,1189,933,955]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8811C81BB379D8" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">3.3</td><td box="[1257,1322,933,955]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B11C81A3C79D8" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">55.1</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF11AA1A3C79BE"><th box="[125,854,967,989]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF11AA1C4079BE" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">White edge on cephalic fins when rolled</th><td box="[923,1029,967,989]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5911AA1B1379BE" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">100</td><td box="[1098,1189,967,989]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8811AA1BB379BE" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">26.9</td><td box="[1257,1322,967,989]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B11AA1A3C79BE" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">23.5</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF11851A3C799E"><th box="[125,1322,1000,1021]" colspan="4" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF11851A3C799E" pageId="24" pageNumber="25"><emphasis bold="true" box="[125,198,1000,1021]" id="B90BE455FFA4EA5CFFBF11851FD0799E" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Ventral</emphasis></th></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF16641A3C7E7C"><th box="[125,854,1033,1055]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF16641C407E7C" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Spots only in the abdominal region</th><td box="[923,1029,1033,1055]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5916641B137E7C" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">75</td><td box="[1098,1189,1033,1055]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8816641BB37E7C" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">2</td><td box="[1257,1322,1033,1055]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B16641A3C7E7C" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">72.6</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF16461A3C7E22"><th box="[125,854,1067,1089]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF16461C407E22" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Dark mouth coloration</th><td box="[923,1029,1067,1089]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5916461B137E22" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">98</td><td box="[1098,1189,1067,1089]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8816461BB37E22" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">8.2</td><td box="[1257,1322,1067,1089]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B16461A3C7E22" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">3.3</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF16211A3C7E01"><th box="[125,854,1100,1122]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF16211C407E01" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Large/medium spots under 5th gill slits</th><td box="[923,1029,1100,1122]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5916211B137E01" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">98</td><td box="[1098,1189,1100,1122]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8816211BB37E01" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">0</td><td box="[1257,1322,1100,1122]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B16211A3C7E01" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">43.5</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF16001A3C7EE0"><th box="[125,854,1133,1155]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF16001C407EE0" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Dark, uniform, V-shaped pectoral fin shading</th><td box="[923,1029,1133,1155]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5916001B137EE0" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">99</td><td box="[1098,1189,1133,1155]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8816001BB37EE0" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">1.1</td><td box="[1257,1322,1133,1155]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B16001A3C7EE0" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">0</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF16E31A3C7EC6"><th box="[125,854,1166,1189]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF16E31C407EC6" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Pectoral shading present but not smooth and uniform</th><td box="[923,1029,1166,1189]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5916E31B137EC6" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">1</td><td box="[1098,1189,1166,1189]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8816E31BB37EC6" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">9</td><td box="[1257,1322,1166,1189]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B16E31A3C7EC6" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">64.5</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF16DD1A3C7EA5"><th box="[125,854,1200,1222]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF16DD1C407EA5" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Dark mask</th><td box="[923,1029,1200,1222]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5916DD1B137EA5" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">73</td><td box="[1098,1189,1200,1222]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8816DD1BB37EA5" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">5.1</td><td box="[1257,1322,1200,1222]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B16DD1A3C7EA5" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">1.6</td></tr><tr id="354F3A05FFA415BBFFBF16BC1A3C7E84"><th box="[125,854,1233,1255]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFFBF16BC1C407E84" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">Average number of spots outside abdominal region</th><td box="[923,1029,1233,1255]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFC5916BC1B137E84" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">1.3</td><td box="[1098,1189,1233,1255]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB8816BC1BB37E84" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">&gt; 20</td><td box="[1257,1322,1233,1255]" id="769E5379FFA415BBFB2B16BC1A3C7E84" pageId="24" pageNumber="25">2.3</td></tr></tbody></table></document>